Originally published in the Business Post: Read in full at https://www.businesspost.ie/property/an-eu-solution-to-an-irish-housing-problem/
Watch back: iProperty Radio https://youtu.be/AItBUSUxtLA?si=KeWLsWN8OcBV43Nh
’15 or 20 ways of building houses’: Ciaran Mullooly’s EU vision for fixing Ireland’s housing crisis
Carol Tallon meets Ciaran Mullooly MEP, the newly appointed vice-chair of the EU Special Committee on Housing to break down the EU’s likely crisis response
Sitting in The Harbour Hotel in the heart of Galway Docks, I am joined by a familiar face with a new title.
Ciaran Mullooly MEP, formerly a household name from his three decades as an RTÉ broadcaster, is now the recently appointed Vice-Chair of the European Parliament’s new Special Committee on the Housing Crisis. As the EU prioritises addressing what has become a pan-European challenge, Mullooly offers a fresh perspective from Ireland’s rural heartland.
“Housing is as big an issue in most of Europe as it is in Ireland,” he explains, dispelling any notion that our persistent housing woes are uniquely Irish.
“We may feel we have the crisis under hand, but there are crises in Portugal, Spain, France, Holland—all across the EU.”
This widespread challenge prompted European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen to create the position of EU Commissioner for Housing and Energy, a brief now held by Denmark’s Dan Jørgensen.
The Commissioner is tasked with addressing the root causes of housing supply issues and unlocking both public and private investment for affordable and sustainable housing solutions – a mission that aligns perfectly with Mullooly’s new role.
From broadcasting to Brussels
Mullooly’s transition from media to politics might seem abrupt, but he reveals that behind his public broadcasting career lay decades of community development work.
“Throughout my time with RTÉ, what people didn’t know is that I’ve been deeply involved in community and rural development as a volunteer,” he said.
After leaving broadcasting, he worked for a Leader company, engaging with social housing and social inclusion matters.
“I whetted my appetite on community development needs, looking at our towns in the Midlands and West of Ireland, seeing the changing face of them, and the serious problems with infrastructure, particularly in housing.”
When Independent Ireland approached him to run for office, Mullooly decided to “put his money where his mouth was.” The rest, as he says, is history, or perhaps history-in-the-making.
Originally published in the Business Post: Read in full at https://www.businesspost.ie/property/an-eu-solution-to-an-irish-housing-problem/ A new EU housing agenda
The special committee’s brief is substantial, with two key priorities: developing a European Affordable Housing Plan and crafting a European Strategy for Housing Construction.
Mullooly has already identified four areas that will receive particular focus under his vice-chair role.
First is what he describes as “a minor programme of decentralisation around the country” —an idea previously controversial in Irish life but perhaps less so today.
“I’m proposing that throughout Europe, we look at the opportunity of taking pressure off our major cities, trying to get away from Dublin’s sprawling housing, from Lisbon’s problems, from Madrid’s,” he said.
This approach involves joined-up thinking: “Take a city like Galway – examine the feasibility of taking a brand new government department out of Dublin and building housing for its staff and families on land owned by the state here in Galway.”
He cites the significant land around Merlin Park HSE complex as an example. “I’m not saying it can be done – I’m saying we should look at it for the first time.”
Ironically, this push for decentralisation comes at a time when much of Ireland’s planning function has been centralised. Mullooly acknowledges this tension.
“We have asked in certain zones in regional development if it’s possible to expedite the planning process.”
The key issue, he notes, is speed.
“If you need fast answers to a problem, you need a fast planning process. You need a good appeal process. We want to see housing planned and constructed within a five-year spell, not just going into planning.”
Rural housing revival
Perhaps most significant for rural communities is Mullooly’s third focus area: revisiting one-off housing policies.
“As a rural MEP based in a really rural part of the country, I would be keen on revisiting the area of one-off housing,” he said unequivocally.
“Local authorities all over the country have a strict policy on this, but I think at this point, with advances in technology and environmental facilities for new housing schemes, we have to go back and revisit the situation whereby a family member is not allowed to build on the parents’ land.”
This position reflects a growing recognition that current rural housing policies may be fundamentally flawed.
The lived reality of Ireland’s current planning regime is that we do not have a positive policy for one-off rural housing; Ireland has, at best, limited exemptions to policies disallowing one-off rural housing, which plays into the notion of decline of rural areas.
Rural decline is inevitable if these areas are starved of social capital; promoting liveable sustainability is the mechanism to halt and reverse rural decline.
The Covid-19 pandemic has shifted perspectives on rural living, Mullooly contends.
“Covid showed that in emergency situations, we can adjust, and we have to adjust. If you say we haven’t got enough land for housing in Ireland, then it goes without debate that we avail of the State land which is available for social purposes.”
State-led housing solutions
Discussing the European strategy for housing construction, Mullooly points to the Austrian model as a potential template.
“What von der Leyen and Jørgensen are looking at initially is the Austrian model … In Austria, as high as 15 per cent of housing is actually built and constructed by the state, provided as cost rental.”
This state-led approach challenges conventional Irish wisdom about property ownership.
“The Irish dream that our mother and father always planted – own your own home, get on the first rung of the ladder – perhaps sometimes doesn’t make economic sense, particularly for small families starting out. It may be better to have a rental situation and evolve over time.”
The discussion touched on past success, back to a time when the State directly built housing and, over a lifetime, facilitated people buying these homes, which strengthened communities and created generational wealth that enabled families to start sending children to third-level education who had never done it before.
“As I said at the outset, one or two measures won’t solve this problem. We’re going to need 15 or 20 different ways of building houses, 15 or 20 different ways of getting in. We’ll still need investors and the private sector.”
Community engagement
For a politician new to the European stage, Mullooly maintains a remarkably grassroots approach. He and the Committee are travelling the country, meeting communities to understand diverse housing needs.
“Every town is different,” he said.
“A town like Galway or perhaps Renmore, with its existing army base, would have very different requirements from Clifden. The more housing development groups we have coming together, the better.”
One practical proposal he is advancing is changing the EU’s funding mechanism for social housing from retrospective to upfront.
“Instead of the old system in Europe whereby funding for housing schemes is retrospective, I’m trying to encourage the Commission to provide advanced funding of up to 70-75 per cent. That helps to get projects started earlier.”
This seemingly small bureaucratic change could have outsized impacts for organisations with a proven track record of delivery and good governance.
“Most of our groups spend most of their time trying to find funding. If we could get the funding upfront, I think it would be key to doubling the number of starts in social housing in a year.”
Raising expectations
When asked what we can realistically expect from the EU Housing Committee in its first year, Mullooly outlines several concrete deliverables.
Initially, thorough research will identify the varying challenges across Europe.
“The European Parliament Research Agency has a very fine reputation. I’ll be asking them to come to Ireland to gather good quality intelligence from the building sector, the social sector, and others.”
Later in the year, we can expect hearings with “principal movers and shakers in banking, planning, finance across Europe, explaining why the money isn’t there, why the average couple trying to borrow €200,000 is having problems with the bank.”
One early recommendation Mullooly hopes to advance is housing for people with disabilities.
“We have a fairly shocking situation in this country where up to 60,000 people who should be living at home alone are living in nursing homes because we have not empowered local authorities and communities to build houses properly facilitated for people with disabilities.
“I think that’s something that can be done much quicker, and I’d like to see that on the agenda for the first 12 months.”
It is clear that Mullooly is not interested in, nor tolerant of, a ‘business as usual’ approach to tackling Ireland’s housing crisis.
While he is clearly optimistic about potential progress, he has a keen awareness of the challenges, particularly in breaking through inter-departmental dynamics that have stalled housing delivery.
“Let’s get down and do it,” he concludes simply.
It is a refreshingly direct approach to a problem that has seen its fair share of complexity and obfuscation.
Originally published in the Business Post: Read in full at https://www.businesspost.ie/property/an-eu-solution-to-an-irish-housing-problem/
You can also watch this interview through iProperty Radio at https://youtu.be/AItBUSUxtLA?si=KeWLsWN8OcBV43Nh

