NewsBUSINESS POST: Think slow, act fast: lessons from mega-projects to guide Ireland’s infrastructure future

Home / Latest News / Business Post / BUSINESS POST: Think slow, act fast: lessons from mega-projects to guide Ireland’s infrastructure future
lessons from mega-projects to guide Ireland’s infrastructure future
April 5, 2025

 

Think slow, act fast: lessons from mega-projects to guide Ireland’s infrastructure future

Like tattoos, marriages and large-scale projects, a slow and meticulous approach is needed rather than making rushed (and costly) decisions

Read in full at: https://www.businesspost.ie/property/think-slow-act-fast-lessons-from-mega-projects-to-guide-irelands-infrastructure-future/

Last November, the European Infrastructure Conference took place in Dublin. It was the right event, in the right place, at just the right time.

Bringing together key stakeholders from across the construction and infrastructure sectors, the focus was firmly on learning from project experience.

Given Ireland’s lack of experience delivering ‘mega-projects’ or those costing in excess of €1 billion, this was quite the coup for the Irish industry. Among the highlights of the conference, the organiser recommended the recently published book ‘How Big Things Get Done’ by renowned Oxford professor Bent Flyvbjerg and bestselling author Dan Gardner.

The book’s sobering insights on the pitfalls of large-scale projects provide critical lessons that are painfully relevant to our current and future infrastructure ambitions in Ireland.

So, what do tattoos, marriages, and large-scale projects have in common? All three require careful deliberation before committing, yet all three frequently suffer from rushed decisions.

Flyvbjerg and Gardner’s book leans on the data, which is stark: a staggering 91.5 per cent of major projects go over budget, over schedule, or both. Only 0.5 percent deliver on cost, time, and promised benefits.

Even more striking is the authors’ analysis of over 16,000 projects from 136 countries across 20 different fields. Their database reveals the scale of this problem across sectors: transportation, IT, infrastructure, and even large- scale events like the Olympics.

Despite the lessons learned from past failures, the same patterns persist.

Flyvbjerg calls this the ‘ Iron Law of Mega projects’: over budget, over time, under benefits, over and over again. From Boston’s Big Dig (triple its budget) to Scotland’s parliament building (978 per cent over budget), the authors show that this pattern repeats globally and across sectors.

Most of us in the Irish construction industry know the statistics intuitively, even if we don’t track the precise numbers. The question is: why does this pattern persist despite our awareness of it?

Flyvbjerg and Gardner argue that successful projects follow the pattern of ‘think slow, act fast’, while failures do the opposite.

The Empire State Building, completed on time and 17 percent under budget in 1931, exemplifies this approach. The builders spent significant time planning before construction began, testing designs rigorously and knowing “exactly how many beams and of what lengths, even how many rivets and bolts would be needed” before breaking ground.

The commitment to methodical planning allowed them to move swiftly during construction, leading to a timely and cost-effective completion. This philosophy, ‘think slow, act fast’, stands in sharp contrast to the common tendency to rush into large projects without proper analysis, which often leads to disastrous results.

What is stopping even those professionals experienced in delivering large-scale projects from adopting this proven approach?

The authors identify what they refer to as the commitment fallacy— a tendency to rush into projects without adequate planning, drive n by a mix of psychology and politics, where political and psychological pressures lead to premature decisions that overlook long-term consequences to achieve a short-term win.

There is an uncomfortable sense of familiarity about that in an Irish political context…

Lessons for Ireland’s ambitious projects

As Ireland embarks on generationally transformative infrastructure projects like MetroLink— the largest infrastructure project in the history of the State— these lessons are particularly relevant.

Dr Sean Sweeney, MetroLink’s new Programme Director, brings valuable experience from delivering New Zealand’s first metro line. His appointment comes as the project approaches critical milestones. The pressure to move quickly on such projects is immense.

As Sweeney himself has noted to the industry, “The ‘do nothing’ approach doesn’t work, and the ‘delay’ option just means we end up paying more.”

Yet paradoxically, rushing into construction without thorough planning is precisely what leads to those higher costs.

Ireland faces significant challenges in housing shortages, infrastructure deficits, and climate adaptation needs. Funding and structural delays, including securing the necessary planning permissions, can lead to a temptation to rush through project planning phases in order to deliver. However, we must resist the instinct to hastily commit without laying a solid foundation.

Like tattoos and marriages, our major infrastructure projects deserve careful thought and strategy before we commit; but once we commit, we must move swiftly and decisively.

Flyvbjerg and Gardner’s research suggests several principles for success, including the need to understand the odds of success (or rather, failure). This means acknowledging the statistical reality of project risks, particularly given the vast data set from more than 16,000 global projects.

To mitigate these inevitable risks, the authors identify that successful projects are built on paper, or through lego, in advance of the actual build. BIM, or building information modelling, enabling digital twins of the building to be delivered in advance of the physical building is the modern day equivalent.

This is one mechanism to master the unknown unknowns, helping project teams to anticipate and therefore plan for unexpected challenges.

For Ireland’s construction and real estate sectors, these insights could not be more relevant or more timely. As we tackle major projects in the coming years, the cost of rushing will be high— not only in financial terms but also in the quality and sustainability of the outcomes.

These projects represent a significant opportunity to build a resilient, modern infrastructure for Ireland’s future. But to succeed, we must prioritise careful planning. The most successful projects in history were not built in a rush; they were built on plans that were meticulous, tested, and comprehensive.

The time to think is before— not after— we commit.

Carol Tallon is chief executive of Property District, founder of Proptech Ireland and a Planning graduate

Read in full at: https://www.businesspost.ie/property/think-slow-act-fast-lessons-from-mega-projects-to-guide-irelands-infrastructure-future/

 

Carol Tallon