Download the Act in full at https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2024/act/34/enacted/en/pdf
The Planning and Development Act 2024 marks a significant step in Ireland’s planning system, with newly appointed Minister for Housing, James Brown, tasked with overseeing its implementation. At 906 pages, the new Act is the third largest piece of legislation in the history of the Irish state and has been positioned as the cornerstone for Irish planning for the coming decades. While objectively not the radical reform that was promised, reforms within aim to streamline planning decisions, providing greater efficiency and certainty for industry stakeholders. The government has emphasised that these reforms will ensure a more predictable and effective planning process, which is critical for developers and investors navigating legal and regulatory challenges.
A key aspect of the new Act is the revision of the judicial review (JR) process in planning decisions. In this context, Judicial Review is the mechanism by which an application can be made to the High Court to challenge the decision making processes (i.e. not the decision) of a public body. The previous system often led to prolonged delays and uncertainty, impacting major infrastructure and housing projects. The Act introduces several key changes to improve the process. The requirement to seek court approval before filing for a judicial review has been removed, meaning that any individual or body with a sufficient interest in the matter can apply directly to the High Court. Applicants must now submit all arguments and evidence at the outset, as amendments during the process are no longer permitted. Under the new Act, an applicant must have a ‘sufficient interest’ in bringing the judicial review, meaning an applicant must be – or have the potential to be – directly, or indirectly, materially affected by the outcome. It is worth noting certain exceptions relating to climate and environmental impacts. Additionally, stricter eligibility criteria have been introduced for residents’ associations. To bring a JR, associations must now be incorporated for at least a year, have a minimum of ten members, and secure a two-thirds majority vote before proceeding. They must also disclose the names and addresses of all supporting members. Furthermore, the timeframe for residents’ associations to file for a JR has been reduced to eight weeks from the date of the planning decision, significantly limiting the opportunity for late-stage legal challenges.
The Act also introduces significant changes to the cost structures associated with judicial reviews. Previously, if an applicant successfully challenged a planning decision, the public body was required to cover legal costs, while unsuccessful applicants were only responsible for their own legal fees. This system was designed to ensure that individuals and groups could challenge unlawful decisions without excessive financial burden. Under the new provisions, a fixed cost regime will be implemented, effectively bypassing the independent legal cost adjudication process. There are concerns that if costs are set too high, access to judicial review may become unaffordable for many, potentially deterring valid legal challenges. It is worth noting that legal practitioners have warned that the new system could introduce unnecessary layers of bureaucracy and uncertainty, potentially leading to further delays rather than expediting planning decisions.
For developers, the Planning and Development Act represents a shift (not a radical overhaul) in how planning permissions and legal challenges are managed. The Act’s new provisions are expected to bring greater certainty in planning decisions by reducing the likelihood of unexpected delays caused by legal disputes. The government’s intention to accelerate the planning process is welcomed by industry players, who have long struggled with delays that inflate project costs. The revised judicial review framework provides greater clarity on eligibility, reducing the risk of frivolous or last-minute challenges that could disrupt major developments. However, industry stakeholders remain cautious about potential implementation issues and the risk of increased bureaucracy. There are concerns that legal disputes over the new cost structures and eligibility criteria could lead to fresh delays, counteracting the Act’s goal of efficiency. As the government begins the phased implementation of the Act, we will closely monitor its real-world impact on planning and development projects in Ireland – email in confidence to share your experiences carol@caroltallon.com.
Ultimately, the success of these reforms will depend on their practical execution. Developers, planners, and industry professionals must adapt to the new framework, ensuring compliance with revised judicial review rules and navigating the evolving cost structures. We need to move beyond any ‘us vs. them’ positioning and rebuild trust across communities (https://placeengage.com/) and media (https://www.publicconsultation.ie/inside-construction). The hope is that these changes will lead to a more predictable and functional planning system—one that enables much-needed housing and infrastructure projects to proceed with greater certainty and speed.
