NewsTaskscapes, Island Endurance & A New Future for Inis Oírr Lighthouse

Home / Latest News / Reading / Taskscapes, Island Endurance & A New Future for Inis Oírr Lighthouse
June 7, 2026

placemaking for Island and coastal communities

The flashing light over Aerodróm Inis Oírr is the last thing I see at night from my home. This weekend I was delighted to participate in an open day for the lighthouse there – well done to all at the Comhar Caomhán, together with Údarás na Gaeltachta and The Commissioners of Irish Lights, on an important first step in the development of Inis Oírr Lighthouse, ensuring its future, for the benefit of the island community.

On a personal note, it was great to climb the lighthouse tower for the first time, and to explore the Keepers’ dwellings. This is a special piece of heritage for the island. Also, thanks to the team at Áras Éanna for hosting the community afterwards in this super facility.

A working landscape (or taskscape) stays alive BECAUSE people are doing things in it – and securing Inis Oírr’s lighthouse for the island community, rather than embalming it as a monument to the past, is exactly the livelihood approach rural and coastal Ireland needs.

In anticipation of this event, I re-read Island Endurance, by Ryan Lash (Amazon link: https://amzn.to/4psKdbD). I picked up this book on Inishbofin last summer and the author’s approach to ‘taskscapes’ makes so much sense in the context of understanding what decades of successive government policies have gotten so wrong about rural and coastal Ireland. You can read my thinking upon first reading here: ‘Island Futures, Taskscapes and Rural Policy: What Ireland’s Offshore Places Teach Us About Viability Beyond Resilience’: https://caroltallon.com/island-futures-taskscapes-and-rural-policy/

And while it’s good to have the academic rigor applied to the argument in favour of people living and working within a landscape, the BurrenLIFE project demonstrated this on the ground – literally. This project – which went on to become an EU exemplar used to guide future rural innovation partnerships – demonstrated that farming plays a vital role in maintaining the Burren. The diversity and biodiversity of this landscape cannot be managed in isolation from the farmers. In fact, reduced farming activity over decades had led to the slow degradation of priority habitats through under-grazing, abandonment and the loss of land management traditions, namely, Winterage (https://caroltallon.com/walking-the-cattle-home-2025-burren-winterage-and-irelands-living-heritage/), which has now been added to a UNESCO inventory of Intangible Cultural Heritage celebrating living cultural heritage practices in Ireland.

The key rule on environmental protection is that when we know better, we do better. So land management now involves implementing such practices as new feeding systems, redeployment of existing livestock, and targeted scrub removal. 

Why is this relevant?

With new rules on rural living promised this summer, there has been an outcry from well-intentioned environmentalists. What the land tells us is that a place stays alive because people are doing things in it. The taskscape – the daily round of work and activity – is the place. Take away the activity and you don’t preserve the place; you embalm it. And only what is dead should be embalmed.

Rural and coastal Ireland has always been a working landscape. The stone walls, the field patterns, the harbours, the boreens, the turf banks – none of these are scenery. They are the physical residue of generations of tasks: farming, fishing, cutting, building, repairing, walking the same routes at the same times of year. The character tourists – and tourism policymakers – prize was produced by people living and working there, in rhythm with tides, seasons, and weather. 

The look of the place is downstream of the life of the place.

Current planning policy often gets this backwards. It treats the landscape as a finished object to be protected – fix the view, restrict the building, limit the activity. But preservation by not allowing life is a contradiction. When you stop young families from building a home near where they grew up, when you make it unviable to fish or farm at small scale, when you zone working harbours for amenity rather than work, you don’t freeze the place in its admired state. You remove the very tasks that made it that way. The walls stop being mended. The land goes to scrub or to holiday lets. The school closes. The taskscape thins out, and within a generation the “preserved” landscape is a hollowed-out one – visually declining, and functionally dead. A village of empty second homes has the fabric but none of the rhythm.

The livelihood approach is to protect the place by protecting the conditions for living in it. That means treating housing for local people, viable small-scale farming and fishing, working harbours, and rural enterprise not as threats to the landscape but as the things that sustain it. A home built and lived in keeps a family in the parish, keeps the activity going, keeps the taskscape intact. The goal is continuity of dwelling, not suspension of it.

Experience shows that a working landscape cannot be conserved by stopping the work. The most genuine form of preservation is to keep the place inhabited and active – to let the taskscape carry on. Landscapes are constituted through ongoing human dwelling and activity rather than existing as static objects, so policy that allows life is policy that actually protects what people say they want to protect.

 

*I am currently working on a framework for helping rural self-builders to establish a biodiversity baseline for their site: Email carol@caroltallon.com to discuss 

 

Carol Tallon